Do non-white Americans pay a ‘respectability tax’?

| August 13, 2013

By Noel King
Special to the NNPA from the Marketplace Wealth and Poverty Desk

“Respectability tax” is a term we invented. It refers to the extra lengths that some African Americans, and other people of color go to, in order to telegraph that they are middle-class, successful, and respectable. Historians say the notion of “racial respectability” took root in U.S. culture after slavery ended.

“African Americans were trying to figure out: how do we live up to the promise of America?” said Celeste Watkins-Hayes, a sociologist from Northwestern University. “How do we make sure that we have the economic, the educational, the political and the social rights that we supposedly have now?”

It has persisted until today, said Lester Spence, a political scientist from Johns Hopkins University, because African-Americans are still trying to live up to that promise.

“At stake are a variety of zero-sum resources,” Spence said. “Your ability to get a job. Your ability to get a raise. Your ability to maintain a job. The argument is if you do not carry yourself in a certain fashion, you are not going to get access to a variety of resources that you need to live.”

When we asked the question—on social media—whether people of color feel they pay a “respectability tax,” a lot of our listeners answered in the affirmative. They came from across the economic spectrum. Kelli White, an African American high-school teacher from Saginaw, Mich., who grew up with Marketplace Wealth & Poverty producer John Ketchum, said her mother always warned her to look professional when speaking to potential employers—even when she was in high school and simply stopping by a business to pick up a job application. Her mom would say, “People are already going to look at you and say, ‘Okay, she’s black. Let’s find something else wrong with her.’

“You’ve already got one strike against you, so you don’t go out of the house putting a second strike on yourself,” White said. For her, that means making sure her clothing is always neat and pressed.

JoAnn Holmes is an attorney and an executive at a beverage company. She is “probably in the top two percent of black income earners in the United States,” and travels, with her teenage daughter to places like Tokyo, Hawaii and Vail, Colo. Often, she said, they are the only African Americans present.

“I’m thoughtful about the way I speak,” Holmes said. “I’m thoughtful about the way that I dress. And, generally, I’m mindful of being courteous and interacting in a way that helps people feel comfortable with me.”

Laura Warren, who is Native American, told us on Facebook that she feels pressure to keep her yard looking nice, because she and her African American husband are among the only people of color on their block. Richard Garcia, who is Hispanic, overheard a comment made by a nurse right after his son was born. She asked another nurse whether Garcia and his wife needed a translator. Since then, Garcia, whose first language is English, has felt compelled to be the most articulate person in the room. And Shauna Stuart’s mom told her on her first day of college that she shouldn’t play hip-hop music in the dorm or people would get the wrong idea about her.

Not all of our listeners agreed that the respectability tax is real. Some said our question was fundamentally flawed. They argued that white Americans from lower or middle class backgrounds face exactly the same challenges. Several said we were only helping to feed a “victim complex,” that, they argue, has persisted in America for decades. Others took issue with our use of the term “people of color,” pointing out, quite rightly, that white is also a color. Still, the sheer number of those who engaged with the question only raises more questions about what it means to be perceived as respectable in America.

For more stories from the Marketplace Wealth and Poverty go to www.marketplace.org/wealth-poverty/.

 

This article originally appeared in the Aug. 7 print edition.

Category: National, Opinion

About the Author ()

Frost Illustrated is Fort Wayne's oldest weekly newspaper. Your Independent Voice in the Community, featuring news & views of African Americans since 1968.

Comments are closed.